32 YEARS AFTER MICHAEL AND ALEX D!ED, SUSAN SMITH IS DENIED PAROLE AGAIN — THEIR FATHER SAYS THE PAIN STILL FEELS LIKE YESTERDAY

32 YEARS AFTER MICHAEL AND ALEX DIED, SUSAN SMITH IS DENIED PAROLE AGAIN — THEIR FATHER SAYS THE PAIN STILL FEELS LIKE YESTERDAY

More than three decades after the deaths of her two young sons shocked America, Susan Smith has once again been denied the chance to walk free. During an emotional parole hearing on November 19, the convicted killer expressed remorse and asked for another opportunity. But the boys’ father, David Smith, delivered a heartbreaking message to the board: 32 years may have passed, but to him, it still feels like yesterday.

Susan Smith, the South Carolina woman convicted of drowning her two young sons in 1994, will remain behind bars after the state’s parole board unanimously rejected her latest request for release.

Now 55, Smith appeared virtually before the South Carolina Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services on Thursday, November 19, seeking parole for the second time.

The decision came 32 years after the deaths of her sons, Michael, 3, and Alex, just 14 months old.

The six voting members of the parole board rejected her application in a 6–0 decision. One member recused herself because of a previous connection to the prison where Smith had been incarcerated.

Smith will now have to wait until 2028 before she can apply again.

Phiên điều trần xin ân xá của Susan SmithTHE CRIME THAT SHOCKED AMERICA

The case dates back to October 25, 1994.

Smith drove her car, with Michael and Alex strapped into their car seats, to John D. Long Lake in Union County, South Carolina.

She allowed the vehicle to roll into the water, leaving her two young sons trapped inside.

In the days that followed, Smith told authorities and the public that a Black man had carjacked her vehicle with the children still inside.

For nine days, the story sparked an extensive search and national attention. Smith made emotional public appeals, pleading for the safe return of her boys.

But the story eventually collapsed.

Investigators uncovered evidence that contradicted her account, and Smith ultimately confessed to causing her sons’ deaths.

In 1995, she was convicted of murder and sentenced to life in prison after the jury chose not to impose the death penalty.

Prosecutors argued that she killed her children because she wanted to pursue a relationship with a wealthy man who had ended their affair.

Her defense, meanwhile, pointed to her mental health struggles, including postpartum depression.

Alex Smith, Michael SmithSUSAN SMITH ASKS FOR ANOTHER CHANCE

During Thursday’s hearing, Smith addressed the board from prison and expressed remorse for what she had done.

She acknowledged that Michael and Alex were innocent children who never deserved to die.

She also apologized directly to their father, David Smith, recognizing that he had been robbed of the opportunity to watch his sons grow up.

She told the board that she had changed, matured and wanted the chance to contribute positively to society if released.

Her attorney argued that she had demonstrated rehabilitation during her years in prison and could become a productive member of the community.

Supporters also spoke on her behalf, including family members and a prison employee who described the ways she had helped other incarcerated women.

The board acknowledged that Smith had maintained a clean disciplinary record during the two years since her previous parole hearing.

However, those arguments were not enough to secure her release.

DAVID SMITH: “32 YEARS HASN’T CHANGED THE HEARTACHE”

Perhaps the most emotional moment of the hearing came when David Smith, the father of Michael and Alex, spoke against his former wife’s release.

He traveled to Columbia to make sure the board understood that the passage of time had not erased the devastation caused by the deaths of his children.

Pinned to his jacket over his heart was the same photograph of Michael and Alex that had once circulated around the country during the search for the missing boys.

It was a photograph he had carried during previous proceedings, including Susan’s first parole hearing in 2024.

David asked the board to look at the picture through his eyes and remember the two children who never had the opportunity to grow up.

“Thirty-two years hasn’t changed the heartache,” he said.

He also questioned whether 32 years in prison could ever be considered enough for what happened.

David made clear that he believed the killings were deliberate, not an accident or a mistake.

His current wife, Tiffany Smith, also spoke against parole, describing the continuing pain her husband experiences and the family’s struggle to live with the loss.

She questioned why Susan should be given the opportunity to walk free when Michael and Alex never received the opportunity to live their lives.

WHY THE PAROLE BOARD SAID NO

The board ultimately cited several reasons for denying Smith’s application.

These included the seriousness of the crime, the potential risk to the community and concerns about her attitude toward family and authority.

Although her defense highlighted her prison record and mental health treatment, prosecutors argued that her release could bring further distress to the victims’ family.

Tommy Pope, the former chief prosecutor in Smith’s 1995 trial, also appeared before the board.

He argued that the family should not have to relive the case and defend the decision to keep Smith imprisoned every two years.

Pope also raised concerns about the public attention Smith could attract if released, given the notoriety of the case.

More than 10,000 people had reportedly submitted opposition to her release ahead of the hearing.

WHY WAS SHE ELIGIBLE FOR PAROLE AFTER A LIFE SENTENCE?

One question that has followed the case is how Smith could even apply for parole after receiving a life sentence.

The answer lies in South Carolina law at the time of her conviction.

When Smith was sentenced in 1995, people serving life sentences under the applicable rules could become eligible for parole after serving 30 years.

The state changed its law the following year, making people convicted of certain serious crimes ineligible for parole under life sentences.

However, the change did not eliminate Smith’s eligibility under the law that applied to her original sentence.

She first appeared before the parole board in November 2024, after serving 30 years.

That application was also unanimously rejected.

Under the rules governing her case, she can submit another application every two years.

ANOTHER TWO YEARS BEHIND BARS

Thursday’s decision means Susan Smith will remain incarcerated until at least her next parole review in 2028.

For David Smith and the family, however, the decision does not bring back the two boys whose lives were taken in 1994.

The grief has remained part of their lives for more than three decades, and every new parole hearing forces them to revisit a tragedy they have never been able to leave behind.

For Michael and Alex, there will be no birthdays, first days of school, bike rides or milestones growing up.

Their father continues to speak for them, determined that their memories will not be overshadowed by the possibility of their mother’s release.

The parole board has made its decision for now.

But for the family, the fight to keep Susan Smith behind bars may return again in two years.

Michael and Alex were only 3 years old and 14 months old when their lives ended. More than 32 years later, their father is still fighting to make sure their voices are heard.