“PRESERVED FOREVER”: CHILLING EVIDENCE FROM CHRISTA PIKE’S 1995 MURDER CASE REMAINS LOCKED INSIDE A TENNESSEE COURTHOUSE VAULT

“PRESERVED FOREVER”: CHILLING EVIDENCE FROM CHRISTA PIKE’S 1995 MURDER CASE REMAINS LOCKED INSIDE A TENNESSEE COURTHOUSE VAULT
More than 30 years after 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer was murdered in Knoxville, the clothing, weapons and personal belongings presented during Christa Pike’s trial are still being preserved by Knox County officials. Their renewed attention comes as Pike faces an uncertain future following her failed September execution.
Inside a secured storage area beneath the City County Building in Knoxville, Tennessee, a collection of objects connected to one of the state’s most notorious murder cases remains under court custody.
A pink sweater bearing a shoe print. A bloodstained cloth gag. A small meat cleaver. Matching necklaces decorated with pentagram symbols. And a black leather jacket connected to one of the most disturbing details in the investigation.
These are not newly discovered items. They are physical evidence from the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer, a 19-year-old Job Corps student whose killing led to Christa Pike receiving a death sentence.
Now, Knox County Criminal Court Clerk Mike Hammond has explained why the evidence is still being kept decades later.
INSIDE THE VAULT: OBJECTS THAT HAVE NOT BEEN DISCARDED
According to Hammond, the case is classified as a capital case, meaning the evidence must be retained indefinitely under Tennessee’s record-retention requirements.
Even if Pike is eventually executed, the items will not simply be destroyed.
Among the preserved objects is Slemmer’s pink sweater, which bears a visible shoe impression on the back. Investigators also recovered her clothing, including a green Karizma jacket, dirty sneakers and jeans marked by mud and damage.
Another item is a small meat cleaver, which remained wrapped in the brown paper bag used to preserve it after the investigation.
A cloth gag was also retained. Investigators said it had been forced into Slemmer’s mouth during the attack, and some of her hair remained knotted in the fabric.
The collection also includes personal belongings connected to Pike and her boyfriend, Tadaryl Shipp, including matching pentagram necklaces that were presented during their trials.
THE BLACK LEATHER JACKET AND THE SKULL FRAGMENT
Perhaps the most disturbing item in the collection is Pike’s black leather jacket.
During the investigation, authorities discovered a piece of bone inside one of its pockets. At trial, forensic experts demonstrated that the fragment fit into a missing section of Slemmer’s reconstructed skull.
The discovery became a significant piece of physical evidence in the prosecution’s case.
The jacket had reportedly been left at the Knoxville Job Corps Center after Pike visited an administrator’s office. Employees later turned it over to authorities, who discovered the bone fragment inside.
The fragment itself should not be confused with an item still being stored inside the jacket today. Reporting by WBIR says Slemmer’s skull and the recovered fragment were eventually returned to her mother, May Martinez, around 2009.
WHAT HAPPENED TO COLLEEN SLEMMER?
Slemmer was a student at the Knoxville Job Corps Center when she became caught in a conflict involving Pike and Shipp.
On January 12, 1995, Pike, Shipp and their friend Shadolla Peterson lured Slemmer away from the center with an invitation to smoke marijuana.
The group went to a remote area near the University of Tennessee Agricultural campus.
What followed was a prolonged and brutal attack. Prosecutors presented evidence that Slemmer was beaten, cut with sharp objects and struck with a piece of asphalt.
According to testimony and Pike’s statements to investigators, Slemmer begged for her life.
The prosecution also described how a pentagram was carved into the victim’s chest during the assault.
Pike was 18 at the time of the crime. Shipp was 17, while Peterson was 19.
Pike and Shipp were later convicted in connection with Slemmer’s murder. Pike received a death sentence in 1996.
A FAILED EXECUTION HAS BROUGHT THE CASE BACK INTO THE SPOTLIGHT
Pike, now 50, was scheduled to be executed by lethal injection on September 30, 2026.
The procedure did not end as planned.
Her attorneys say two doses of pentobarbital were administered, but problems with the intravenous lines may have caused the drug to leak into surrounding tissue rather than properly enter her bloodstream.
Pike survived and was transported for emergency medical treatment. Her lawyers later reported serious injuries to her arms and a prolonged period of critical illness.
She has since returned to a Tennessee prison facility and has described continuing pain.
The failed procedure prompted an independent review and a suspension of further executions in Tennessee for the remainder of 2026.
A NEW LEGAL FIGHT OVER THE EXECUTION DRUGS
The legal dispute has continued into November.
On November 10, the Associated Press reported that Tennessee officials were seeking to prevent Pike’s attorneys from inspecting or testing leftover pentobarbital from the September procedure.
The state argues that access to the drug vials and their labels could expose the identity of a confidential supplier, information protected under Tennessee law.
Pike’s attorneys say they are not trying to identify the supplier. They want to examine how the drug was labeled, stored, transported and prepared, and whether it may have been expired.
That examination, they argue, could help explain why the execution failed.
The dispute follows an earlier court order requiring Tennessee officials to preserve evidence connected to the attempted execution, including drugs, syringes, IV equipment, medical supplies, photographs, recordings and other documentation.
MORE THAN THREE DECADES LATER, THE EVIDENCE REMAINS
The objects in the Knox County vault belong to a case that changed the lives of multiple families forever.
For Slemmer’s mother, May Martinez, the loss has never simply become a matter of old court records. She had expected to witness Pike’s execution on September 30, but the procedure ended without Pike’s death.
For Pike, the failed execution has opened another chapter of legal uncertainty.
And for Knox County officials, the evidence from the original murder case remains subject to a requirement that it be preserved indefinitely.
More than 30 years after Colleen Slemmer’s death, the pink sweater, the cleaver, the jewelry and the jacket remain reminders of a crime whose consequences are still unfolding.